The worst bridge in American history is this one, according to observers

On May 4, 1873, a catastrophic event unfolded in Dixon, Illinois, which would leave an indelible mark on the history of bridge engineering in the United States. The collapse of the Truesdell Bridge, occurring during a baptism ceremony by the Rock River, tragically claimed 46 lives and injured at least 56 others. This disaster is considered one of the worst in American bridge history, both in terms of fatalities and injuries​​​​.

The Background of Truesdell Bridge

Named after its designer Lucius Truesdell, a self-taught engineer, the bridge was constructed using a novel system of trusses and rods designed to support iron bridges. Despite earlier signs of instability in Truesdell’s designs, the city of Dixon, plagued by frequent floods and seeking a durable solution to bridge failures, accepted his design over 14 other proposals.

The city council’s decision, even amidst warnings from the city engineer, led to the erection of the bridge at a cost of $75,000, with the bridge operating as a toll bridge​​​​.

The Fatal Day

The Dixon Bridge Disaster occurred as a large crowd gathered on the bridge’s pedestrian walkway, about 15 feet wide and 150 feet long, to witness a baptism. The bridge, supported by massive trusses 30 feet above the walkway, began to sway and creak under the crowd’s weight.

A loud crack prefaced the sudden collapse, plunging people and bridge parts into the river. The shallow water did little to mitigate the impact as the fallen trusses pinned many victims, resulting in a horrific scene of chaos and tragedy​​​​.

The Aftermath and Impact

The collapse resulted in a public outcry and demands for justice. The city of Dixon sued Truesdell and his company for negligence and breach of contract. The trial, after a series of proceedings, found Truesdell and his company liable, awarding damages to the city.

The disaster had far-reaching implications, exposing the flaws in Truesdell’s design and leading to its eventual abandonment. It also ushered in a new era of bridge engineering and safety, with the development of rigorous standards and regulations emphasizing scientific and professional approaches based on mathematics, physics, and materials science​​.

The Town of Dixon During the Disaster

Dixon, at the time of the collapse, was a growing town, a primary crossing point over the Rock River. The city had experienced significant growth in construction and infrastructure, including the construction of two bridges, one for rail and the other for pedestrians and vehicles.

The city had a history of bridge failures, with at least eight wooden bridges across the Rock River having been destroyed over the years due to high water and ice jams​​.

Response and Recovery Efforts

The immediate aftermath saw extraordinary efforts by the citizens of Dixon. They quickly mobilized to rescue the living and recover the dead, utilizing ropes, planks, and boats. The community came together in a remarkable display of humanity, offering aid and resources to the injured and grieving. The tragedy led to the suspension of business and school closures as the town mourned the victims​​.

Placing Blame and Seeking Justice

In the aftermath, blame was assigned to various parties, including Truesdell, the Dixon City Council, the bridge tender, and even the Baptists conducting the baptism. However, the case against Truesdell’s bridge design sustained scrutiny over time.

The press, sensitive to public official misconduct following the Crédit Mobilier Scandal of 1872, speculated that corruption played a role in the disaster. Ultimately, the responsibility for the bridge disaster was linked to both the contractors and the authorities who authorized its construction​​​​.


The Truesdell Bridge Disaster stands as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of engineering failures and the importance of rigorous standards in public infrastructure projects. It also highlights the resilience and solidarity of communities in times of crisis.

This tragic event not only transformed bridge engineering but also left a lasting impact on the town of Dixon and its residents, who came together to support one another in the face of unimaginable tragedy.