The Top 5 Pizza Cities in America Are Selected From Pennsylvania

Pizza, a universally adored dish, serves not just as a quick meal but as a canvas for culinary creativity and cultural expression. In the bustling tristate area of New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, pizza is more than food—it’s a piece of cultural heritage, a testament to culinary craftsmanship.

The residents of these states, often considered connoisseurs of the dish, have long debated the superior style and taste of pizza. However, it’s Pennsylvania that has recently earned significant accolades in the pizza world.

A comprehensive list compiled by Pizzello, an authoritative culinary website, has spotlighted the top 250 cities in the United States renowned for their pizza offerings, revealing where enthusiasts can find the crème de la crème of this beloved dish. This list, which ranks cities based on their average Google review scores, has brought unexpected fame to five Pennsylvanian cities, affirming their status as must-visit destinations for pizza aficionados.

Scranton: A Slice of Heaven

Ranked 13th nationwide, Scranton emerges as Pennsylvania’s top city for pizza lovers, boasting an impressive average rating of 4.52. The city’s love for pizza is epitomized by Anthony’s Restaurant American and Italian, a local favorite according to Yelp reviews. This establishment, celebrated for its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere, is a testament to Scranton’s vibrant culinary scene.

Bethlehem: A Historic City with Modern Flavors

Claiming the 77th spot with an average rating of 4.50, Bethlehem marries rich history with contemporary tastes. Paranormal Pizza stands out in this historic city, offering an extraordinary dining experience that transcends the ordinary. With a stellar Yelp rating of 4.8, it’s a cornerstone for both locals and visitors craving a unique pizza experience.

Allentown: A Blend of Tradition and Innovation

Allentown, ranking 80th, continues Pennsylvania’s streak with another average rating of 4.50. The city’s standout, Vinny’s Pizza and Restaurant, has garnered attention with a Yelp rating of 4.6. Known for its traditional recipes with a modern twist, Vinny’s has become a symbol of Allentown’s culinary evolution.

Erie: The Lakeside Pizza Destination

At number 127, Erie adds a lakeside charm to Pennsylvania’s pizza landscape, scoring an average rating of 4.46. The city’s pizza crown jewel, Ippa, has captivated locals and travelers alike with a Yelp rating of 4.8. This spot is celebrated for its quality ingredients and inventive recipes, making it a beacon for pizza lovers.

Philadelphia: A Cultural Melting Pot of Flavors

Philadelphia, known for its rich history and diverse culture, secures the 153rd spot with an average rating of 4.45. Circles + Squares leads the charge, offering a unique pizza experience that reflects the city’s eclectic spirit. With a Yelp rating of 4.8, it’s a must-visit for anyone seeking to explore the depths of Philadelphia’s pizza scene.

These rankings not only highlight the diversity and quality of pizza available in Pennsylvania but also underscore the state’s growing reputation as a culinary destination. Whether you’re a fan of traditional, thin-crust, or inventive pizza creations, Pennsylvania’s offerings underscore the state’s commitment to culinary excellence and innovation.

As the pizza scene continues to evolve, these cities remain beacons for those in pursuit of the perfect slice. The recognition of these five cities on a national platform is a testament to Pennsylvania’s rich culinary landscape, inviting pizza enthusiasts from around the country to explore its flavors and traditions.