Lawsuit Filed Against School for Failing to Stop Bullying That Left 12-Year-Old Brain Damaged in South Carolina

Honk News– The family of a harassed teenager who attempted suicide has sued the school.

The family of a South Carolina teenager who suffered lasting damage after attempting suicide as a result of chronic bullying has filed a negligence lawsuit against her school district.

According to the lawsuit filed on November 12, Kelaia Turner first complained about being bullied by other students at Greenville County’s Dr. Phinnize J. Fisher Middle School in August 2021. She was eleven years old at the time. However, the bullying not only continued for a year and a half, but it was apparently encouraged by some of the school’s teachers.

The lawsuit accused the school and nine middle school teaching and administration personnel of “negligent, grossly negligent, reckless, and wanton acts” that resulted in Kelaia Turner’s attempted suicide in March 2023.

According to the lawsuit, in December 2021, pupils referred to Turner as “a man and roach in [teacher] Olivia Bennett’s class.” Bennett was accused of being “complicit” in the bullying and “said nothing to the other students to stop it.”

When one pupil reportedly said, “Where’s the roach?” Bennett reportedly aimed toward Turner.

Kelaia’s mother, Ty Turner, detailed several more insults and racist slurs that her daughter had received from classmates in an October 2024 Facebook post, including “Mustache Face,” “Ugmo,” and “FatBlackUgly.”

Another incident described in the lawsuit occurred in May 2022, when Turner’s classmates played a racist YouTube video in class in an attempt to taunt her. John Teer, the teacher of that class, “allowed the song to be played without any comment on its offensiveness, nor any reprimand or discussion with the student who played it.”

There were also reports of physical altercations between Kelaia and other pupils, which resulted in Kelaia being reprimanded but not the others. An October 2022 incident detailed a student continually “pushing” Kelaia, but the only action taken by the faculty was to request that the next incident be reported to them. The complaint stated: “The bullying continued, resulting in [Kelaia]’s clothes being hung, water being poured on them, and then thrown into the trash.”

The continual bullying culminated on March 17, 2023, when Kelaia Turner, then 12, “attempted suicide by hanging as a direct result of the bullying of five Fischer Middle students.”

Lawsuit Filed Against School for Failing to Stop Bullying That Left 12-Year-Old Brain Damaged in South Carolina (1)
Image: Greenville County’s Dr. Phinnize J. Fisher Middle School

Ty Turner told WYFF, a local NBC station, that at 11:18 p.m., she saw her daughter “hanging.” When paramedics came, “She was cool to the touch, blood was coming out of her nose, and she had already urinated on herself. She had fully committed to what it was that she was attempting to do, and she was gone for eight whole minutes. They couldn’t find her pulse, and they couldn’t find her heartbeat. There were grown men in the room crying.”

Kelaia Turner was revived and spent 101 days in the hospital, including many weeks in a coma. She ultimately sustained “significant brain damage.” Ty Turner told WFYY “Kelaia has no control currently over her body. She’s total care, nonverbal, on a trach, on a feeding tube. She requires around-the-clock care that, for the most part, is administered by her father and I. We’ve recently gotten the help of a nurse three days a week.”

To make matters worse, in the days following Kelaia’s hospitalization and 31-day stay in the intensive care unit, some students were given access to her while she was unconscious and photographed her with the intention of mocking her further on social media. According to the complaint, “[a]fter the pictures were circulated, [another student] also assisted in spreading rumors about [Kelaia]’s injuries.”

The day after those students posted pictures of an unconscious Kelaia, her mother, who was unaware of the photos, emailed the school to file a formal complaint “regarding the lack of enforcement of Fischer Middle’s anti-bullying policies,” claiming that Kelaia “had been reporting incidents of bullying since 2021 with no intervention.”

The principals replied that the school has “a zero-tolerance policy for bullying but no way to enforce it.”

Ty Turner learned about the photographs weeks later.

The lawsuit alleged that “[a]s a direct result of the bullying that had occurred since 2021, [Kelaia Turner] attempted suicide by hanging and is now on total life support with severe brain damage.” She requires 24-hour care.”

Kelaia’s family seeks actual and punitive damages against the school and the nine identified defendants, which a jury will assess.

Reference: Family of bullied girl who attempted suicide sues school